(630) 894-5512

Call us today


Get a FREE Estimate

Roofing Shingles Vs. Cedar Shakes Costs, Plus Pros & Cons

Roofing Shingles Vs. Cedar Shakes Costs, Plus Pros & Cons

Roofing Shingles Vs. Cedar Shakes – Which Is Better?

There are many roofing materials to choose from. You can choose from shakes or shingles. Both of them can live for many years. Messina Builders is here to help you if you need a new roof. We are a construction company in the Chicagoland area. We are experts at building custom homes. We also do other things like repair, additions, and new construction.

We take pride in our high-quality services and attention to detail. Our skilled experts will work with you to ensure your project is done on time and within budget. Our gallery is an excellent place to start if you are still determining what you are looking for. 

Contact us at  (630) 894-5512 to find out more about our services. See our client’s review to have a better view of our work. We would be happy to be a part of your project.

Roofing Shingles Vs. Cedar Shakes

Cedar shakes are a great choice if you want your house to age well. We will talk more about both the costs and the benefits below.

1. Material Costs

When selecting a roofing material like roofing nails and other things, there are many things to remember. Roofing shingles and cedar shakes are popular. Each has distinct benefits, but which is the cheaper option?

Most of the time, roofing shingles are cheaper than cedar shakes. This is because shingles are made in large quantities. They are also from cheaper materials like asphalt or fiberglass.

Cedar shakes are pricier because it is made from cedar wood. They also take more work, which adds to the overall cost. So, shingles are the way to go if you want a cheap way to roof your house. But cedar shakes may be the best choice if you are willing to pay more for a more natural look.

Roofing Installers

2. Installation Costs

Putting on roof shingles is usually cheaper than putting on cedar shakes. This is because shingles come in squares that you can place on the roof quickly and easily. Also, they are made from corrugated roofing metal. 

A different kind of roof is cedar shakes. They must be cut and nailed into place one at a time, which takes longer and costs more. But cedar shakes have a very different look than many homeowners like. Also, cedar is a natural material that will last longer. It might last longer, saving you money in the long run.

There is no clear winner when it comes to installation costs. Which option is best for you will depend on how much money you have and what you like. If you are still determining which option is best for you, you should talk to an expert immediately. They can help you determine which option is best for your home based on your needs and budget.

3. Aesthetics

When it comes to the outside of your home, you have a lot of options. Choosing the right material for the roof is important. Roofing Shingles and cedar shakes are two of the most common choices. Since they both look different, it comes down to what you like best.

Shingles for roofs come in many different colors. Often, you can find a color that goes with the siding on your home. Asphalt shingles are made of asphalt and have smooth surfaces. Cedar shakes are made from split logs. Their rough surface is left unfinished or stained with a light color to make them look old. 

When it comes to looks, everyone has their own opinion. Shingles on roof will give it a classic look. Cedar shakes might be a good choice if you want something different.

Roofing Shingles For Aesthetics
Roofing Shingles For Aesthetics

4. Durability

There is no clear winner between the two when it comes to how long they last. Both materials are meant to keep the weather out of your house. Each material, though, has its pros and cons.

Asphalt and fiberglass shingles are very strong and last a long time. But they can be damaged by hail, strong winds, or trees that fall on them. Cedar shakes are also powerful, but they burn. Before choosing a material, it is important to think about what your home needs.

5. Repair And Maintenance

You can do a few things to fix or replace your roof. People often choose asphalt shingles, but you could also use cedar shakes.

 Asphalt shingles are cheaper than other kinds, but you must fix them more often. Cedar shakes cost more, but they last longer and do not need as much maintenance.

Asphalt shingles are a good choice if you want a roof that is easy to take care of and does not cost too much. If you want to spend more money upfront on a rooftop that will last longer, cedar shakes might be a better choice. Your budget and what is most important will determine which roofing option is best for you.

When deciding between shingles and cedar shakes, consider all the factors. This includes the climate you live in, the style of your home, and how much money you want to spend. Messina Builders has experience with both types of roofs and can help you decide which is right for you. 

We are a home building company that has been around for a long time. We build all kinds of homes using different building methods. We also do things related to building homes, like design, construction, and remodeling.

We also have a gallery of completed projects where you can see examples of our work. We can help you with both buildings, a new home, and making changes to an existing one. We will work with you to design your dream home while keeping your budget in mind. Contact us at  (630) 894-5512 to begin working on your project.

Messina Builders Offered Services:

We've Hand-Picked These Articles For You:

Frequently Asked Questions

The amount of maintenance required is the most significant disadvantage of cedar shake siding. To keep moss, algae, and mold at bay, cedar shakes must be cleaned on a regular basis. Surface treatments are also necessary to protect them from the elements, including moisture, insects, and fire.

The time-consuming shake roof maintenance required to ensure your natural wood roof lasts 30 years can cost nearly $1000 per year, not including repair costs.

Aside from their stunning natural beauty, cedar shingles are a popular roofing material among homeowners and builders because they can last up to 50 years if properly maintained

The lifespan of a dimensional asphalt shingle roof is approximately 30 years. A cedar shake roof has a 30-year lifespan, but it could last up to 50 years if you invest in quality materials and live in an area with the right conditions.

Furthermore, cedarwood contains natural oils that repel insects and rot; both of these properties help ensure that your investment lasts longer than fences made from softer wood varieties. The disadvantage of cedar wood is that it naturally greys with age.

Underlayment should never be installed on shakes unless an ice barrier is required over solid sheathing. Interlayment is required instead. The interlayment is an 18-inch-wide strip of 30-pound black felt installed between shake courses.

Skip to content